The creator behind viral parody channel There, I Ruined It just delivered one of the most thought-provoking talks about AI and creativity. Opening with what seemed like a 1937 blues song that “inspired” David Bowie’s “Starman,” he revealed it was 100% AI—a clever deception that perfectly illustrated his point about authenticity and artistic intent.
Dustin Ballard, Creative Director at Dallas-based TRG—an IAN member agency—works on campaigns for brands like TotalCare and Dallas Human Rights by day. By night, he “lovingly destroys” music for millions of followers, often using AI voice cloning to create bizarre mashups like Conway Twitty singing 50 Cent’s “In Da Club.” But his TED talk wasn’t about the laughs—it was about the serious questions AI raises for all creators.
When AI feels too real
Ballard’s opening gambit worked because the AI-generated blues song felt authentic—until people learned it wasn’t. That emotional shift reveals something crucial about how we experience creative work. The pain in the nonexistent bluesman’s voice “felt a little wrong” to Ballard himself, even though he created it.
“If I hear a song I love on the radio, am I going to stop everything and research how that song was created?” Ballard asked the audience. Probably not. But the question of whether creativity requires human experience keeps nagging at anyone working with these tools.
The spectrum of AI music
Ballard demonstrated the wide range of AI applications in music creation. He showed his process of using AI voice models to transform his Conway Twitty impersonation into something virtually indistinguishable from the real thing. He also played his Red Hot Chili Peppers grocery list mashup, complete with before-and-after vocals that revealed how AI enhanced his original performance.
The range spans from simple lyric assistance (like a rhyming dictionary) to completely synthetic performances. “The term AI music doesn’t really clarify anything,” Ballard noted, highlighting the confusion even among lawmakers—including Rep. Matt Gaetz’s response to a Ballard creation: “Robots should not be subject to free speech.”
Three ethical guardrails
Faced with limited regulatory guidance, Ballard developed his own framework for responsible AI use:
Is it deceptive? Could someone reasonably believe this is real without disclosure?
Is there artistic intent? Mass-producing hundreds of AI songs for Spotify probably isn’t art.
How does this affect other musicians? When artists like Snoop Dogg share his AI mashups on social media, Ballard sees it as validation that he’s contributing something new rather than just copying.
The creativity multiplier effect
Ballard’s most compelling argument is that AI can amplify human creativity rather than replace it. By giving him access to different voices and instruments, AI expands his creative palette. He compared it to a guitarist using different guitars—why should he be “stuck with the voice I happen to be born with?”
He purchased his coworker’s voice for a Leonard Cohen-style cover of “Baby Got Back”—a transaction that’s both hilarious and forward-thinking about voice as intellectual property.
What John Philip Sousa would think
Ballard closed with historical perspective, noting that every new musical technology—from phonographs to synthesizers to sampling—initially faced skepticism. John Philip Sousa called phonographs “a substitute for human skill, intelligence and soul” that “reduce the expression of music to a mathematical system.”
Sound familiar?
His final creation—”The Phonograph,” a Nickelback parody about photographs and phonographs—was exactly the kind of absurd creativity that Sousa couldn’t have imagined. Ballard’s wife called it “the stupidest thing I’ve ever seen.” The audience loved it.
The talk suggests that AI music’s future depends less on the technology itself and more on the humans wielding it. For independent agencies working with AI tools, Ballard’s ethical framework offers a practical starting point: be transparent, maintain artistic intent, and consider the impact on the creative community.
As the Creative Director at IAN member agency TRG put it, “There are ways to use AI that can actually increase creativity.” The key is remembering that the human behind the technology determines whether that creativity builds something new or just copies what already exists.
Learn more
There, I Ruined It
TRG
Dustin Ballard LinkedIn
- About the Author
- Latest Posts
