The independent agency world โ news, work, people and thinking.
The Ponytail Problem, the Four-Second Cliff and a Raccoon in the Ceiling
Indie Agency News members spent the past week counting things. 212,961 football comments. 27,000 landing pages. 980 award submissions whittled to 96.
Even the agencies that weren’t running numbers were busy measuring something: how much a ponytail is worth, how long a brand can wait for its owner to finish the website copy, how many years it takes to find the right building. Meanwhile, the AI conversation has moved past “will it replace us” and toward a more practical question about who stays in charge of the output.
And for anyone who thinks agency life is all spreadsheets, there’s a tattoo, a fictional HR department for a neighborhood and a raccoon.
8 numbers from this week’s feed
The data you’ll be quoting in meetings by Thursday.
NFL fan comments from Weeks 1 to 9, run through ellain. Creativ Company.
Conversion at four seconds, down from 3.05% at one second. White Rabbit Group, via Portent.
Of shoppers 60+ have used TikTok search for beauty. Stella Rising.
Of US physicians use AI at least monthly. Klick Health.
Canadians watched the deciding game of the Stanley Cup Final. GTE Canada.
Entries selected from 980 for the CA Advertising Annual, Sukle among them.
Names of people lost to gun violence in Chicago, built into one film. Six+One.
In wheel locks given away ahead of a big day for virtual car theft. WorkInProgress.
Numbers worth stealing
The data you’ll be quoting in meetings by Thursday.
Ran 212,961 fan comments from Weeks 1 to 9 of the NFL season through its ellain cultural intelligence platform. The San Francisco 49ers came out on top at +25.99% and the Los Angeles Chargers sit at −31.50%. Across the league, overall fan perception slid from +4.19% in Week 1 to −2.21% by Week 9.
Pulled Portent’s study of 27,000+ landing pages: ecommerce sites that loaded in one second converted at 3.05%, at three seconds 1.12% and at four seconds 0.67%. It also made the case that speed fixes stall because nobody owns them, with the theme agency, app vendors and marketing team each holding one piece of the store.
Has new research that takes apart the idea that social search is a Gen Z thing. Even among shoppers 60+, 37% have used TikTok search for beauty, and people in their 30s are the most active TikTok searchers of any age group. SEO Manager Reilly Phelps explains why that belongs in every beauty brand’s SEO plan.
Its latest Klick Wire found that 91% of surveyed US physicians use AI at least monthly, while a separate study found health information in 22% of AI conversations.
Its Future of Entertainment research found that 64% of fans have already written, drawn or built something that adds to a world they love. Household calls them Active Authors and argues most location-based entertainment is still designed for spectators: queue, look, photograph, leave.
Points out that 3.8 million Canadians watched the deciding game of last season’s Stanley Cup Final, and calls live hockey the last mass, simultaneous audience in the country.
Humans still hold the steering wheel
Everyone has the same tools. The difference is who’s deciding what they make.
Executive Director of Creative Technology & AI Kai Tier joined Atlas Cloud at ADWEEK House: Commerce Summit to ask whether more content is creating more value. His line: “A brand needs to be adaptive to be able to meet the modern consumer expectations.” That thinking sits behind Barbarian’s Adaptive Brand Solutions.
VP of Data & Innovation Ron Hadler offered three moves for brands worried about AI describing them: make your brand guidelines public, say things the same way everywhere and build structured content modules for AI to pull from.
Kevin Walker asks whether AI needs mascots too, arguing that the more we need technology to feel human, the more human creativity matters.
SVP, Head of PR & PA Trish Nugent wrote for Destinations International on what synthetic audience research can and can’t do for destination marketers. Her advice: use it to complement real audience insight, not replace it.
Took the stage with Google’s Stephanie Horton at The Female Quotient AI Summit in NYC, where Jen Passaniti summed up their work through Google’s Creative Lighthouse Program: “AI did not replace our creativity. It SAVED IT.” The work includes a three-minute cinematic film about a tire.
The agency math department
Margins, fees and the owner who’s holding up the website.
Drew McLellan and fractional CFO Niall Cotter dig into why growing agencies are often “confidently wrong” about their finances, including why a 5% margin on a $20 million agency is more fragile than 20% on a $5 million one, and how three monthly ratios line up with AMI’s 55-25-20 benchmark.
In a solo episode, McLellan opens with a confession about the owner bottleneck: AMI’s new website is designed, built and tested, but can’t launch because the copy is sitting on his desk.
The Agency Business podcast brought on APR CEO Patrick Lafferty to discuss the changing economics of production, including the slow shift away from time-based compensation, who pays for AI tools and who owns what they create.
Danielle Wiley and Casey Benedict unpack why a single percentage fee says almost nothing about the work behind an influencer campaign. Managing 25 micro creators takes very different resources than two celebrity contracts, and margin is not profit.
CEO Leeann Leahy joined Justin Levinson on the Agency Side Podcast to talk about doubling revenue with a leaner team, giving every VIAn a stake through the agency’s ESOP, testing a four-day work week and resigning a major client.
Wrote about why brands that add an agency to their in-house team often pay twice and get less than half: a tired brief, not enough contrast in the team and blurred lines between buyer and seller.
New names on the roster
Pasta sauce, peanuts and a pickle emoji.
Has been named Social and Cultural Agency of Record for Mizkan America across RAGÚ, Bertolli, Mizkan, Holland House and Nakano.
Is the new AOR for the National Peanut Board, handling media, strategy and creative.
Welcomed four new clients: Harvard Pilgrim Health Care, The Greater Boston Food Bank, Waldron Civic and IEc.
Won a strategic and creative assignment for Reser’s Fine Foods covering its deli salads line.
Picked up two more Lufthansa mandates: email and CRM marketing through Plan.Net, plus creative lead for Lufthansa Group’s global B2B marketing.
Onboarded a new client and told us nothing except ๐ฅ๐. We’ll be watching.
Work that picks up the phone
Hotlines, quilts, diapers and a very honest dog campaign.
Gave Hudson Square its own fictional Chief Neighborhood Benefits Officer, Grant King, complete with a proudly outdated onboarding film and a working hotline: 1-607-HSQ-PERK. It made Ad Age’s “17 Creative Campaigns to Know About Today.”
Separately, Six+One built ‘This Is Our War’ from the names of more than 10,600 people lost to gun violence in Chicago. It marks the Prime Video release of a documentary executive produced by Denzel Washington and Six+One founder Eric Rojas.
Launched a new brand campaign for Hertz that began as a real-life stunt and grew into a company ethos.
Wants you to skip the bad presents and give the greatest sh*tty gift: diapers. Nearly one in two U.S. families with young children struggle to afford them.
Its new spot for Food Bank of Central New York is built around a quilt made by the Towpath Quilt Guild, each patch telling a different story about food insecurity.
Its campaign for SPCA New Zealand pits raising kids, wellness fads and the midlife crisis against life with a rescue dog, cut from real social footage that the Special team sent in.
Its latest playbook looks at how brands earn trust on Reddit by giving up the script. It starts with Dove letting 50 Redditors write a campaign and keeping its promise not to edit, even after one reviewer said it smelled like an old lady.
Noticed November 19 is shaping up to be a huge day for virtual car theft, so Belle Tire, Big Brand Tire & Service and their family of brands are giving away $200,000 in wheel locks to protect the real ones.
Teamed with Ad Council and Oscar-winning director Sam Davis on “Rideshare,” a buzzed-driving PSA that puts young men’s futures in the back seat.
Its clients said nice things about them, so they turned the testimonials into songs.
Hardware with specifics
Trophies, and how many of them.
Was named ADCC Agency of the Year for the sixth year in a row, along with 4 Gold, 40 Silver and 28 Bronze awards.
Its “Do more. Do less. Do something.” campaign for the Denver Climate Project earned an Award of Excellence in Communication Arts’ 2026 Advertising Annual. It was one of 96 entries selected from 980, and one of just 12 integrated campaigns.
The campaign included 70 headlines, an upcycled fashion line, pollution-free pedicab rides and a custom ice cream flavor.
Was named Agency of the Year at The Lovie Awards, with 5 Gold, 6 Silver, 1 Bronze and 4 People’s Lovies across seven projects.
Took home three Golden Drums at The Drum Awards in Miami for Pearson’s “See Yourself Bigger,” which asked three graduates what they’d tell their younger selves.
Its “Check, Mate” for Voices of Alzheimer’s earned Gold for Film/TV/Video Campaign and Silver for Purpose-Led Campaign of the Year at the Ad Age Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards.
At the same show, won the Tiny but Mighty category award for Norton Healthcare.
Never works for free unless it keeps ownership of the idea, so it gave Ad Age exactly what they didn’t pay for and won the first-ever Ad Age Small Agency Network Billboard Challenge.
Birthdays, ink and new front doors
Some milestones get a party. One got a tattoo.
Celebrated 50 years with a legacy that includes Ram Trucks, Chick-fil-A, Motel 6 and Corona. Current work includes a decade of the SEC’s “It Just Means More” and Tripp, the new mascot for Love’s Travel Stops.
Marked its own 50th with Gold at the 2026 Clios Sports Awards for QuikTrip Home Bun.
Turned 10, and CEO Megan Lally and Co-CCO Chad Broude made it official with Highdive tattoos while Co-CCO Mark Gross quizzed them on agency history.
Spent six years searching Austin before buying a 1970s fixer-upper in 2023, rats and a ceiling-dwelling raccoon included. Four years of renovation later, the space has a Tokyo-inspired meditation room, a screening room and Blind Tiger, a coffee-and-cocktails space where the lobby would usually be.
Finally gave the cobbler’s kids shoes: a new website more than two years in the making. It replaces a Squarespace site thrown together in a week that somehow lasted four years, and there’s a not-so-hidden video game in there.
The fine print
Two reminders that legal risk shows up in strange shapes.
Partner Jim Johnston spoke with WIPR about Erling Haaland’s dispute with Norwegian Air Shuttle over a social post that put a digitally recreated version of his blond ponytail on the tail of a Boeing 737, with the line “We’ve never looked more Norwegian.” His question for brands: does that use diminish the value of his endorsement in the travel category?
Warns that if your MSA predates your team’s AI use, it may promise things you can’t deliver, like full IP ownership of work that may not be ownable at all. Sharon Toerek walks through two risk areas and five steps with Logan Lyles on December 3.
Want your agency’s news in the next Indie Spin? Members get their work, wins and thinking in front of the people who pay attention to indies.
Become an IndieHQ member