The Monkey’s Paw of “Ship My Pants” and Other Tales Told Around the Agency Campfire

Indie Spin: The one with a cursed Kmart wish, a 16-year goodbye to IKEA, and a mirror that only shows famous brands.

It’s the day before Halloween, and Indie Agency News members are in a storytelling mood. Some of it is spooky by design: haunted retail turnarounds, horror-poster soda and a pumpkin carver on the payroll. Some of it is spooky because it’s about AI search.

Fewer than a third of Google searches now send anyone to a website, and LLMs still account for less than 1% of site traffic, yet several members land on the same cure for both: be the brand people already say out loud. Elsewhere, a long partnership closes its final chapter, a seven-year awards streak ends with real grace and a fifth of American households are rewriting their grocery lists.

The receipts

8 numbers from this week’s feed

Members did the math. These are the ones worth repeating in your next meeting.

<1%

Of website traffic comes from LLM referrals today. The brands people already talk about still make it through. SRH.

80%+

No-click share of Google searches when an AI summary appears. Bridge Insights & Media.

215%

Rise in funded grants for TERP, alongside a 135% jump in website traffic. Bridge Insights & Media.

14x

ROAS from search for L’Occitane, with a 21% lift in branded search driven by video. Stella Rising.

341K

Views for a “This or That” with Lando Norris across TikTok and Instagram. Saylor.

79%

Of ransomware incidents start with a compromised identity or a legitimate login. Yes& Agency.

14mo

Payback on a new donor, the number that lands with a CFO better than CPA. Delve Deeper.

16yrs

Of Mother and IKEA, told by 16 of the people who made the work. Mother.

Tales from the agency crypt

Campfire stories, each with a marketing moral.

Spun a bedtime story about Kmart’s 2013 “Ship My Pants” campaign as a monkey’s-paw wish: the pun sent crowds into stores whose creaky point-of-sale software and supply chain couldn’t deliver what the ads promised. Not content with one fable, the agency followed with a Frankenstein tale of Abercrombie & Fitch’s resurrection, walking through the Four P’s that took the retailer from “assuming room temperature” in 2017 to record net sales near $5 billion.

Partnered with a professional pumpkin carver to create the promotional art for the Minnesota Zoo’s Jack-O-Lantern Spectacular, which glows through this Halloween weekend.

Launched HOT TAMALES’ “Live on Flavor’s Edge” campaign for Just Born, built entirely on hand-drawn illustrations.

Goes live on Zoom today at 10am PT with “Brand Momentum After Dark: The Science Behind the Scare,” using its Brand Momentum Score to unpack what put horror fans in seats for a recent release.

Say my name

Mirror, mirror, which brand does the chatbot pick?

SRH

Also compared LLM brand discovery to summoning something through a mirror. LLM referrals drive less than 1% of website traffic today, but because models predict answers from consensus, the brands people already talk about are the ones that make it through the glass.

Says fewer than a third of Google searches now send a click to a website, and when an AI summary appears, the no-click share passes 80%. When client TERP paired upstream awareness with digital capture, website traffic rose 135% and funded grants rose 215%.

CEO Lauren Ridgley wrote in MediaPost that AI isn’t a shortcut, it’s a mirror, digging into early research on which brands AI tools recommend and finding the answer points back to old-fashioned brand building.

Lead Content Strategist Kelly Brown ran hundreds of searches and found that AI-generated content won’t help a brand show up in AI search. Human insight worth citing is what wins, so she rebuilt her content framework around it.

Asks who you’re marketing to if AI does the shopping, arguing the best salesperson in your category already works for ChatGPT or Perplexity and cares about clear product pages and strong reviews, not ad budgets.

President John Faris points out that websites now serve two audiences, people and bots, and some of those bots bring security risks and higher hosting bills. The agency digs in at its November 4 Speaker Series, “Do you even need a website anymore?”

Closing credits and new openings

Goodbyes, rebrands and fresh paint.

Said goodbye to IKEA after 16 years, and Campaign UK let 16 of the people who made the work tell the stories behind it: 100 cats loose in a store, a Matt Berry-voiced shelf in Skyrim and 500 FRAKTA bags taken apart by hand.

CCO Amy Ferguson told Breaking and Entering Media that clients won’t take the agency’s advice if it can’t take its own, so the agency took hers and rebranded. There’s a notebook for proof.

Is marking 50 years of building brands by giving its own some love, with a brand-new website and more features promised.

Developed “Greater Together,” the strategic platform at the heart of the Greater Philadelphia Chamber’s rebrand.

Fresh off the edit bay

New work, from small business dreams to a cranberry good-luck charm.

Has new work for Gusto about small business dreams, covered by Ad Age’s Tim Nudd, with MJZ and Nick Ball among the credits.

Its first work for RACV was named The Drum’s Ad of the Day. Meanwhile, its global Movember campaign, “Make a Growmitment,” made it onto the big screens in Times Square days before the month begins.

TRG

Also rolled out a cinematic campaign for Charles Schwab about the preparation before a trade, from the muffled calm of “Noise” to the launchpad countdown of “Liftoff.”

Turned a side dish into the main event with a moody, close-up-heavy spot for Idahoan Ultimates.

Launched season three of its Sun Valley Resort work, and this year the mountain community is running the camera.

Helped Mars’ Freedent and Hubba Bubba swap a snacking ritual for a lifesaving one during Pink October in France, with a QR code that drops a monthly breast self-exam reminder straight into your phone’s calendar.

Its LCPR work wishing the Milwaukee Brewers “Berry Good Luck” for the Wisconsin Cranberry Growers Association made Ad Age’s 21 Creative Campaigns to Know About Today. The luck held: Left Hand Agency, wrapping up a team week in Milwaukee, congratulated the Brewers on their first World Series title.

Numbers to bring to your next meeting

Stats worth stealing for the next deck.

Notes that more than a fifth of U.S. households now include someone on a GLP-1. Since brands can’t see medication status, it suggests watching behavior instead: shrinking baskets, protein gaining share and selective indulgences. Its Where Growth Leaks report also tackles why one shopper bouncing between an AI tool, Reddit, a creator video and a store aisle can look like four different people.

Won a 2026 Search Engine Land Award for Best Integration of Search Into Omnichannel Marketing for L’Occitane, where video drove a 21% lift in branded search and 14x ROAS from search. The agency is also a 2026 BeautyMatter Awards finalist for both Best Marketing Agency and Best Digital Agency. And on DoorDash’s plan to acquire Instacart, Associate Director of Retail Advertising Joshua Presnall advises brands to start planning last-mile as a single channel now, even though the deal isn’t expected to close until late 2027 or early 2028.

Developed a social-first “This or That” interview with Lando Norris for Hilton and McLaren Racing that pulled more than 341K views and 36K likes across TikTok and Instagram.

Spotted a volunteer-run “Cosplay Hospital” at London’s MCM Comic Con, armed with glue guns and sewing kits, and tied it to its Future of Entertainment research: 64% of fans say they’ve already written, drawn or built something that adds to a world they love.

Closes out Cybersecurity Awareness Month noting that 79% of ransomware incidents start with a compromised identity or a legitimate login. Not a break-in. A login.

Says that with budget season putting donor acquisition on the chopping block, telling a CFO that new donors pay back their cost in 14 months lands better than CPA and ROAS.

Ask the humans

Creators, Gen Z and a reality check on synthetic audiences.

Surveyed more than 250 creators about posting politics, brand deals and paid political work, and found that creators want in on the midterm conversation, but most haven’t been asked.

Day One Agency

CEO Josh Rosenberg told LBB about Group Chat, the agency’s youth insights focus group. When the agency asked members how they define the American Dream, most said it either no longer exists or is so far out of reach it might as well not.

Chief Strategy Officer Jasmine Dadlani looks at Gen Z’s growing interest in the trades and what it means for marketers well beyond brands that sell trucks, tools or lunch.

Head of Media and Performance Jono DeCosta told The Outcome that before AI-generated audiences guide media decisions, planners need to know those audiences reflect how people behave.

Kat King argues that in the race for faster, cheaper content, brands helped “slopify the feed,” and suggests measuring how many viewers choose to come back as Instagram tests longer-form video.

The trophy case (with a twist)

Wins, juries and one streak that ended in style.

Was the first agency to win Strategy Magazine’s Agency of the Year seven years running, and took this year’s Silver with a cheerful “You can’t win them all,” alongside Gold for PR Agency of the Year (Rethink PR) and Digital Agency of the Year, plus Silver for Design Agency of the Year.

Celebrated Effie Gold and Grand Prix wins for Maple Leaf Foods’ “Look for the Leaf,” crediting No Fixed Address for the idea and noting Canadians were still hunting for the leaf after a 48-hour media blitz.

Its Audi Gingerbread Village, made with Stoopid Buddy Stoodios, is shortlisted for the International Motor Film Awards and The Drum Awards.

Co-Founder and Co-CCO Mark Gross is headed to Austin, with “How to Break the Playbook, not the Brand” selected for SXSW 2027. Chief Strategy Officer Nimisha Jain was also named to the Global Grand Jury for the 2026 Effie Awards Global Best of the Best.

Is your indie agency doing work worth talking about? Members get their wins, thinking and work in front of the indie community every week.

Become an IndieHQ member
Share your love